Star Wars - The Clone Wars
August 19th, 2008
So, the biggest question in the universe has been answered by George Lucas: “How did Anakin Skywalker become Darth Vader?” So… what’s left to care about in the worlds of Star Wars? Plenty if you’re a true Star Wars fan.
In the latest offering from Lucas Animation (the first ever from this new division) we’re treated to a look into the Clone Wars. If you’ve seen the very first movie that came out in 1977, (I saw it at least 10 times in the theatre alone!) you might remember the quiet discussion that Luke and Obi-wan have after he rescues Luke from the Sand people attack on Tatooine. In this conversation Luke asks Obi-wan if he fought in the Clone wars. Since 1977 we’ve always wondered what the clone wars were. Now, that things have been hashed out in the prequels and we know things like Boba Fett’s father was the seed for the clones, that the Storm troopers are actually all identical clones, and that Obi-wan is there on Tatooine because he was forced into hiding at the beginning of the clone wars and to specifically watch over Luke! It’s now time to get into the real guts and action of the clone wars which turn out to be a major part of the Star Wars story. That’s where Lucas takes us this time around. Onto the battle field and into the lives of new characters and deeper into the relationships of old characters.
Some may think that it’s unfortunate that the decision was made to present this part of the Star Wars history as an animated film, but lets face it, Star Wars was made to be animated and they’ve done a great job. I’d love to say that it’s the best Star Wars film or even animated film that I’ve ever seen, but unfortunately it’s not. It’s good. Sometimes it’s great. But it’s not up there with the live action Star Wars films and as far as the story goes and the quality of the character animation it just doesn’t reach the heights that other animated film companies produce. Again, let me stress, it’s good, but the stylized animation style that’s used in the film seems to conflict at times with the overall, high, HIGH, quality environments and for me it was distracting and hard to get past.
Another part of the film that was hard to get past was the flamboyant, evil uncle of Jabba the Hut. This character ranks right up there with Jar Jar Binks on the irritation scale and seriously degrades the feel of the film. Why this character is presented as a purple - possibly gay - member of the Hut mob clan is beyond me. It seems that this character would have been much more believable as an evil mobster (much more evil than Jabba it turns out) if he was portrayed as dark, dirtier than the original, older, extra greasy and, well, darker. This flamboyant character is just out of place and it’s one of the truly bad parts of this film in my opinion.
In the movie there are some tremendous battle scenes, death and mayhem. There were some touching and deep scenes that added depth to the characters and the story. Most importantly though, overall, the film felt like Star Wars which is what ultimately won me over. You can tell that even though this film was directed by someone other than Lucas, you feel that he was a part of it and guiding it. So, I must say that even though this is an animated film, it still stands up nicely as another great chapter in the Star Wars saga. Let’s hope that they can keep the same quality going forward in the new animated series and in the new live action TV series that’s rumored for the future.
NOTE: I drew this picture of R2-D2 when I was 7 years old. Yes, I am an old and true fan. I should also note that I took great pleasure in taking my two sons to see this film (7 yrs old and 5 years old respectively) and they loved the movie just about as much as I loved the first one.
Overall rating: B- (but could have been higher if they chose to improve the character animation)
Overall kids rating: A+
