This is a summary of a post that I made on photo.net on Sep 13, 2003. The incident was actually followed up with an article in our local Ohio paper which I’ll post here. I thought it was interesting how the conversation on this topic is still continuing. Actually, I was reminded about this because I happened to “stumble upon” a conversation about me again on Stumbleupon.com. It’s just a little concerning to me that normal people can be wandering around in public places minding their own business and then get pulled in for questioning. It’s not a big deal and I understand the reasons for it but we need to walk a careful path as we go forward in the world so we don’t become too paranoid, too limiting on our freedoms and too dependent on our government to decide what’s right and wrong. As someone important once said… “It can only lead to the dark side”. Below is the beginning of the post and my story. For further reading on the subject scroll down below the post to read the countless comments and discussions that have sprung up over the years. You can also read more here.
I’m writing this to alert all of you to be very aware WHERE you are shooting while in the United States! Yesterday I was out doing some street shooting and apparently I wandered a little too close to our Federal Building downtown with my camera and I was immediately ran down by four officers, detained and questioned for over an hour.
I currently live in Akron Ohio. A city of about 200,000 people in the northeast United States. During my lunch hour I went out on a beautiful sunny day excited to do some photography. I wandered down main street shooting various subjects for about a half hour and without finding much I wandered a little further down than I normally go which brought by our federal building. I wandered up in front of the building in the courtyard where they have a sculpture. I took several photos of the sculpture (shooting away from the building) I wandered around looking at a memorial they have there and then continued on my way. I crossed the street via the crosswalk and continued down the other side of the street. I took a picture of a woman in a car, a really old TV set in a window and a view of the construction of our new library being built downtown. Soon after I arrived at this spot I heard someone yelling. Being downtown I ignored it. They kept yelling and eventually I looked back and I saw 3 uniformed officers and one plain clothes man running toward me. I was very surprised that they closed in on me and the man asked me to step back over by the officers and he immediately told me to give him my bag and to put my hands above my head. By this time I was surrounded by men with guns and standing on the sidewalk in public view feeling embarrassed and confused without a really good reason since I was clearly out just enjoying the day and minding my own business.
The officer at this point proceeded to quickly go through my bag and he arrogantly asked me “why I was talking pictures of the Federal building and the businesses across the street?” I immediately realized where I was and why they were on me. I was blown away that it did not even cross my mind where I was on the day after September 11th. The officer asked me for my I.D. and proceeded to ask me a few more questions and then told me that I needed to come with him into the federal building so they could check my identification. I was immediately surprised that this had gone on as long as it had because I had a good explanation for what I was doing, I had proper I.D., I don’t look like a suspicious person, I am clearly born and raised in the United States, I was being more than cooperative AND I was in a public place minding my own business!
So I was interested to see how far this was going to go so I went with him. Mostly because I was curious and because I am a quiet, non-confrontational person. I’m not sure I really had a choice though and soon I found myself in the bowels of the basement in a grungy hole in the wall office surrounded by mold and security guards. At this point he asked me a few more questions, he asked me if there was anything that I needed to tell him before he started a background check and then he left me with an armed guard for about 15 minutes.
Read more….